New reviews and notes

  • Sort notes on 
  •   Total notes: 884080
Ruby_C scored this whisky 91 points Expert Junior

  • Nose
    92 92
  • Taste
    91 91
  • Finish
    90 90

yoomin scored this whisky 88 points Newbie

voodoochile scored this whisky 73 points Connoisseur

Well, this could have been interesting, as I do like rye, and most things with port finishes are usually good. But this turned out to be some kind of watered-down alcoholic liquid that has nothing to do with either port or rye.

It’s the worst of both worlds.

The port finish doesn’t complement the rye, it wages war against it. With all means necessary, including weapons forbidden by the Geneva Convention. Maybe also some long-forgotten medieval artifacts dug up from a swamp.
  • Nose
    73 73
    Musty sweetness and a hint of Jägermeister mixed with furniture polish.
  • Taste
    73 73
    Watered-down musty sweetness. Also quite lame. Tastes more like a sugary liqueur than whisky. Probably good for people who just want to get hammered and still want to know exactly where their headache came from the day after.
  • Finish
    74 74
    Luckily, almost non-existent.
    This so-called rye whisky goes down like a brick falling from a roof. And then, poof, it’s gone.
    I don’t mind that at all. That’s its best feature.
    It feels so redeeming I could dance. I considered giving it 100 points for this, but I just can’t. It wouldn’t be fair, as it still tastes bad going down.

Ruby_C scored this whisky 88 points Expert Junior

  • Nose
    90 90
  • Taste
    87 87
  • Finish
    88 88

luxuriant scored this whisky 89 points Expert Junior

2026.6.20
截至目前,仅称得上一支风味干净的老年份雪莉单桶。本次暴力杯醒3个小时风味仍未完全打开,待后续静置瓶醒,期待下次开瓶带来更佳表现。
Nose:
虽高达 56.9% 的高酒精度,初嗅却几乎无酒精冲感,绵密奶油质感包裹鼻腔,闻香柔和温润。雪莉桶非常干净,没有硫的侵扰,闻香表现为:乌梅、椰枣、无花果、中段略有一点浅浅的薄荷和桉树叶,尾端有一丝松烟。充分醒酒后薄荷香气上扬,干烟草气息缓缓浮现。(91分)
Mouth:
入口与香气呈现强烈反差,数十年桶陈赋予浓郁橡木底蕴,整体偏干、微带木质苦韵,好在酒体油润饱满,中和了尖锐刺激感。醒酒后风味顺滑度明显提升,展现出较为明显的乌梅、樱桃、巧克力,但木质香气还是偏硬偏酸,有进一步醒酒的空间。(88分)
Finish:
长,深色果味持久留存,接续桉叶与樟脑清凉感,收尾有一次乌梅的二次袭击,这一点有意思。(89分)
  • Nose
    91 91
  • Taste
    88 88
  • Finish
    89 89

ttjun1 scored this whisky 85 points Newbie

When first opened the bottle, alcohol hit pretty hard considering 15 year, so I decided to let it sit for 3 to 5 minutes. Nothing special when I just opened and sipped. 80/100

After 2 weeks of oxidation
Alcohol hit less on nose, elegant milk chocolate followed by well-ripened grape. mid to long finish. definitely a great daily sipper. 85/100

I got the bottle for 60 USD (Yes I know it was at a bargain when it usually goes for $90 USD), so if the bottle is usually available at $60 USD range, I would say high 80s (88-89), but when considering that the MSRP is somewhere near $90, I would say there are lots of other options that we could choose.

When the older bottle had more characteristics of that moldy wine cask smell with much richer sherry forward notes, I would say newer bottles tend to be more balanced, but less sherry forward (even this is fully aged in sherry cask).

I personally prefer scotches with distillery's characteristics (Clynelish being known for its waxy texture, or funkiness of springbank), so
  • Nose
    87 87
    Raisin, elegant milk chocolate, and a bit of fig
  • Taste
    83 83
    dried fruit, and a bit of nuts
  • Finish
    84 84
    Mid to long finish, typical sherry characteristics, a bit of honey.

Ushangwua scored this whisky 90 points Expert Senior

开放甜蜜的黄果贯穿如一,尾端略带烟草想象的木质味道非常迷人。需要一点时间让其展现最好的姿态,但不需要水。
  • Nose
    89 89
  • Taste
    91 91
  • Finish
    91 91

Ushangwua scored this whisky 88 points Expert Senior

黄色水果,粉状物质,较为厚重的质感,有些拧巴有些平平无奇。大口饮用的话加分不少,甜美的味道会放大,青涩的木质涩味会减少。于我而言,降低酒精度的做法是正确的,我无法想象原桶强度的这支酒会有多少拧成一团的风味。
  • Nose
    88 88
  • Taste
    89 89
  • Finish
    87 87

Ushangwua scored this whisky 91 points Expert Senior

整体果味明显,带有一些老旧木头的味道,中段有完整的质感支撑,尾段略显仓促,瑕不掩瑜。
  • Nose
    93 93
  • Taste
    91 91
  • Finish
    88 88

Widdon scored this whisky 87 points Newbie

"I bought this whisky two to three years ago. Initially, it had a very distinct character—heavy sherry notes, medium-high peat smoke, a strong hint of sulfur, and a fairly spicy, peppery finish. Overall, it felt great and possessed a very unique taste profile; it is definitely not something beginners could easily approach or appreciate.When I reopened it today, however, it had become much softer and mellower overall, with the various flavors beautifully integrated. After adding a few drops of water, it became even more delicious and enjoyable."

2.5YEARS AGO:85
TODAY:88
  • Nose
    86 86
  • Taste
    89 89
  • Finish
    85 85

JWall scored this whisky 87 points Newbie

£59.95. Great stuff. Brown sugar, caramel, little funk, little dirt and earthy. The good Clynelish herbs I like so much, not much wax but slightly there if you look. Little musty and a little spice at the start and fades quick just as I like it. Alcohol is integrated very very well and drinks like a lower 50's abv with a few drops of water. Bought two bottles and happy to have a backup and would buy another when they're gone.

clyne_loganar scored this whisky 92 points Connoisseur

  • Nose
    92 92
  • Taste
    92 92
  • Finish
    91 91

VLG scored this whisky 31 points Connoisseur

Very boring, the Single Grain is much better. The alcoholic bite is insane, it feels like a CS bottling.

On the nose, very nutty, with candied hazelnuts and stale almonds. Some red fruits, honey, and grain. On the palate, very boozy and alcoholic, actually extremely harsh. Vanilla, grain, nuts, an herbal touch. The finish is dominated by stale nuts.

Nah. Not for me. Actually disastrous.

kbs26 scored this whisky 87 points Connoisseur

  • Nose
    89 89
  • Taste
    87 87
  • Finish
    86 86

kbs26 scored this whisky 89 points Connoisseur

  • Nose
    90 90
  • Taste
    89 89
  • Finish
    89 89

kbs26 scored this whisky 85 points Connoisseur

  • Nose
    84 84
  • Taste
    86 86
  • Finish
    85 85

kbs26 scored this whisky 88 points Connoisseur

  • Nose
    87 87
  • Taste
    88 88
  • Finish
    88 88

kbs26 scored this whisky 89 points Connoisseur

  • Nose
    89 89
  • Taste
    90 90
  • Finish
    89 89

Dre73 scored this whisky 86 points Connoisseur

Pleasant, powerful whisky. Spicy, blavk pepper, sweet red fruits, plants.
  • Nose
    86 86
    Full scent, cigar tobacco, some sour fruitiness, apples, apple sirup. Some alcohol noticeable, not punching. Some sweetness, berries.
  • Taste
    85 85
    Powerful, spicy, black pepper. Sweet red fruits, berries, apple sirup. Plant-like as well. Quite some alcohol.
  • Finish
    86 86
    Still powerful, quite some alcohol, black pepper. Red fruits, berries, Fruitella. Pretty long finish. Some plant- and floral notes.

kbs26 scored this whisky 85 points Connoisseur

  • Nose
    85 85
  • Taste
    86 86
  • Finish
    85 85

MarcinSmm scored this whisky 90 points Connoisseur

  • Nose
    91 91
  • Taste
    90 90
  • Finish
    89 89

Dre73 scored this whisky 86 points Connoisseur

Part of a blind tasting. Typical old style blend, amazing how much power this oldie still has, very nice experience.
  • Nose
    86 86
    Full scent, typical old style blend: oily, musty, fruity. Strawberry, some autumn forest-vibes, trees. Hardly any alcohol noticeable. Later on some chocolate as well.
  • Taste
    86 86
    Quite smooth, but present, character. Musty and oily, fruity again, apples, strawberry. Forest-vibes again, tree-like. Full bodied. Far away still some chocolate.
  • Finish
    85 85
    Some power now, slightly present alcohol. Musty again, forest-vibes, fruity, berries. Oily. Medium long finish, where later on the chocolate peeps in again.

MarcinSmm scored this whisky 88 points Connoisseur

  • Nose
    88 88
  • Taste
    89 89
  • Finish
    87 87

BertDX Plus scored this whisky 89 points Expert Senior

Maritieme neus, zilt, kippers, zoete ondertoets van peer, limoen op de BBQ, zoete drop en kaneel, artisjok, roest, peper. Best wel magnifiek! Op smaak datgene wat we zo lekker vinden aan Caol Ila, olieachtig, makreel in olie, jonge groene olijven, vleugje steranijs, potlood. Lange afdronk, kampvuur, peertjes, turf, zilt, zeeuws. BAM! Deze Caol Ila is geweldig lekker, en stel dat je voor dit vat nog 10j langer had gelegen (no criticism) extra ordinair en superlatieven zouden tekort komen. Kudo's aan Jürgen en Patricia voor deze selectie. Cheers.

Jimbeau scored this whisky 87 points Connoisseur

  • Nose
    86 86
  • Taste
    87 87
  • Finish
    87 87

Whiskybase logoWhiskybase

Build and track your whisky collection, rate and review bottles, check prices, and engage with like-minded enthusiasts. All things whisky since 2007.

Become a Supporter 

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

Whiskybase B.V.
Zwaanshals 530
3035 KS Rotterdam
The Netherlands 


KVK: 60207205
VAT: NL853809112B01